Epistle XVIII.

Reply of St. Ambrose to the Memorial of Symmachus, in

which after complimenting Valentinian he deals with three points of the

Memorial. He replies to his opponent’s personification of

Rome in a singularly telling manner, and proves that the famine spoken

of by Symmachus had nothing to do with the cessation of heathen

rites.

Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers: Series II/Volume X/Selections from Letters/Epistle XVIII

, Bishop, to the most

blessed prince and most gracious Emperor Valentianus, the august.

Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers: Series II/Volume X/Selections from Letters/Epistle XVIII

1. Since the illustrious Symmachus, Prefect of the

city, has sent petition to your Grace that the altar, which was taken

away from the Senate House of the city of Rome, should be restored to

its place; and you, O Emperor, although still young in years and

experience, yet a veteran in the power of faith, did not approve the

prayer of the heathen, I presented a request the moment I heard of it, in which, though I stated such things as it seemed necessary to suggest, I requested that a copy of the Memorial might be given to me.

Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers: Series II/Volume X/Selections from Letters/Epistle XVIII

2. So, then, not being in doubt as to your faith, but anxiously considering the risk, and sure of a kindly consideration, I am replying in this document to the assertions of the Memorial, making this sole request, that you will not expect elegance of language but the force of facts. For, as the divine Scripture teaches, the tongue of wise and studious men is golden, which, gifted with glittering words and shining with the brilliancy of splendid utterance as if of some rich colour, captivates the eyes of the mind with the appearance of beauty and dazzles with the sight. But this gold, if you consider it carefully, is of value outwardly but within is base metal. Ponder well, I pray you, and examine the sect of the heathen, their utterances, sound, weighty, and grand, but defend what is without capacity for truth. They speak of God and worship idols.

3. The illustrious Prefect of the city has in his

Memorial set forth three propositions which he considers of

force: that Rome, as he says, asks for her rites again, that pay

be given to her priests and Vestal Virgins, and that a general famine

followed upon the refusal of the priests’ stipends.

4. In his first proposition Rome complains with

sad and tearful words, asking, as he says, for the restoration of the

rites of her ancient ceremonies. These sacred rites, he says, repulsed Hannibal from the walls, and the Senones from the Capitol. And so at the same time that the power of the sacred rites is proclaimed, their weakness is betrayed. So that Hannibal long insulted the Roman rites, and while the gods were fighting against him, arrived a conqueror at the very walls of the city. Why did they suffer themselves to be besieged, for whom their gods were fighting in arms?

5. And why should I say anything of the Senones, whose entrance into the inmost Capitol the remnant of the Romans could not have prevented, had not a goose by its frightened cackling betrayed them? See what sort of protectors the Roman temples have. Where was Jupiter at that time? Was he speaking in the goose?

6. But why should I deny that their sacred rites

fought for the Romans? For Hannibal also worshipped the same

gods. Let them choose then which they will. If these sacred

rites conquered in the Romans, then they were overcome in the

Carthaginians; if they triumphed in the Carthaginians, they certainly

did not benefit the Romans.