_A synthetic proposition is one in which the predicate gives information not necessarily implied in the subject. “Fire protects men from the wild animal.” “A cubic foot of water weighs 62½ lbs.” “The sum of the interior angles of a triangle is equal to two right angles.”_ These are synthetic because a common conception of the meaning of the subject would not need to include the information given by the predicate. Other names for synthetic propositions are _accidental_, _real_ and _ampliative_.
The distinction between analytic and synthetic propositions is not so clear as would on first thought appear. “_Fire burns_” might give added information to the child or savage who knows only of the light emitted by fire. To them, then, the proposition would be synthetic. The distinction must be based upon the assumption that the same words mean about the same thing to people in general.
This analytic-synthetic division of propositions finds a significance in the domain of philosophy. To the logician the distinction is of slight importance save in the so-called verbal disputes, viz.: disputes which turn on the meaning of words.
_A modal proposition states the mode or manner in which the predicate belongs to the subject._ The signs of modal propositions are the adverbs of time, place, degree, manner. Illustrations: “James is walking _rapidly_.” “Honesty is _always_ the best policy.” “Aristotle was _probably_ the greatest thinker of ancient times.”
_A pure proposition simply states that the predicate belongs, or does not belong, to the subject._ Illustrations: “James is walking.” “Honesty is the best policy.” “Aristotle was the greatest thinker of ancient times.”
Some logicians refer to modal propositions as being such as indicate _degrees_ of belief. Such words as “probably,” “certainly,” etc., would indicate their modality.
As logic has to do with the pure proposition and not the modal, the difference of opinion is of little import.
_A truistic proposition is one in which the predicate repeats the words and the meaning of the subject._ Illustrations: “A man is a man,” “A beast is a beast,” “A traitor is a traitor,” “What I have done I have done.”
The truistic proposition is of little importance except in cases where the subject is used extensionally while the predicate is used intensionally. In the illustration, “A man is a man,” the subject merely stands for a member of the man family, while the predicate may indicate certain manly qualities. Against such ambiguities the logician must be on guard.