This piece was written as part of Advox's partnership with the Small Media Foundation to bring you the UPROAR initiative, a collection of essays highlighting challenges in digital rights in countries undergoing the UN's Universal Periodic Review process. As Zimbabwe heads for elections in August this year, electoral watchdogs continue to implore the government to implement meaningful electoral reforms such as availing the digital version of the voters’ roll. However, the body charged with election administration, the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission (ZEC) is firmly resisting these calls citing the need to comply with the Cyber and Data Protection Act 2021. In the interests of transparency and public interest, the conduct of electoral officials has only served to impugn the credibility and integrity of the whole electoral process. Earlier this year, voters received unsolicited text messages from the ruling ZANU PF party, which has been in power for 43 years, highlighting significant information security breaches. Although physical copies of the voters’ roll can be accessed at the ZEC offices, stakeholders argue that the digital version is vulnerable to manipulation by political actors with an interest in determining the electoral outcome. In April this year, ZEC chairperson Priscilla Chigumba told parliament that releasing the electronic version of the voters’ roll, as demanded by opposition political parties, would violate the Cyber and Data Protection Act. Chigumba said that the cyber law has placed additional responsibilities on the commission in terms of the format in which data should be disseminated to the public, in order to protect voters’ personal data. She added that there is need to ensure that the Electoral Act be aligned with the Cyber and Data Protection Act in the interests of ensuring that voters have ready access to the voters roll while guarding the public from identity theft. Her remarks to parliament come shortly after the High Court rejected a lawsuit by Harare North member of parliament Allan Markham, of the main opposition party Citizens Coalition for Change (CCC), seeking to compel ZEC to release the electronic version of the voters’ roll for inspection and audit. In a ruling, Justice Never Katiyo concurred with ZEC that releasing the digital version of the roll would compromise the security of its database. Markham has since taken the matter to the Supreme Court. However, civil society groups accuse the election management body of deliberately violating the constitution, under the guise of complying with the cyber law. Section 11 (5) (h) of the Cyber and Data Protection Act provides that a Data Controller, in this instance ZEC, shall process sensitive data if the processing of data is authorised by a law or any regulation for any other reason constituting substantial public interest. Furthermore, Section 21 (3) of Zimbabwe’s Electoral Act authorises ZEC to “…within a reasonable period of time provide any person who requests it, and who pays the prescribed fee a copy of any voters’ roll either in printed or in electronic form as the person may request.” However, the ZEC has a consistent track record of denying opposition parties and the public access to the voters’ roll. In a statement, independent watchdog, the Election Resource Centre (ERC) argued that ZEC is legally obligated by both laws to avail voters roll data as it constitutes substantial public interest, and its availability is necessary for electoral participation and the realisation of political rights. “The continued denial of the voters roll especially to persons with a legitimate interest in the voters roll and free and fair elections…under the guise of data protection is unlawful and detrimental to the credibility of the 2023 harmonised elections,” the ERC said. In emailed responses to a Global Voices enquiry, human rights lawyer Nompilo Simanje pointed out that the feedback from ZEC as represented by Chigumba highlights a critical legal issue that there is a need for harmonisation of laws. “While access to the voters’ roll is provided for in terms of the Electoral laws, ZEC indeed also has obligations in terms of the Cyber and Data Protection Act which places obligations on the use, transmission and dissemination of data,” she said. Simanje said that this is an issue where a balance has to be found between promoting access to information and promoting the right to privacy. Popular Zimbabwean journalist Hopewell Chin’ono tweeted that without a voters’ roll, the election is already rigged in favour of the ruling party ZANU PF. President Emmerson Mnangagwa of Zimbabwe announced that Zimbabwe’s elections will be held in August. The constitution says it must be held before 26 August.