THE QUESTIONER. Well--er, yes, I had noticed something of the kind! But is that sort of thing necessarily art? I mean--well, I don’t want to attempt to argue with you on a subject in which you are an expert, but--
THE ARTIST. Oh, that’s all right! The modern artist is ready to discuss art with anybody--the more ignorant of the subject, the better! You see, we want art to cease to be the possession of a caste--we want it to belong to everybody. As a member of the human race, your opinions are important to us.
THE QUESTIONER. That is very kind of you. I fear it is rather in the nature of a digression, but, since I may ask without fear of seeming presumptuous,--_are_ those horrid misshapen green nudes of Matisse, and those cubical blocks of paint by I-forget-his-name, and all that sort of thing--are they your notion of what art should be?
THE ARTIST. Mine? Oh, not at all! They are merely two out of a thousand contemporary attempts to recover the naïve childlike vision of which I spoke. If you will compare them with a child’s drawing, or with a picture by a Navajo Indian, or with the sketch of an aurochs traced on the wall of his cave by one of our remote ancestors, you will note an essential difference. Those artists were not trying to be naïve and childlike; they _were_ naïve and childlike. The chief merit of our modern efforts, in my personal opinion, is in their quality as a challenge to traditional and mistaken notions of what art should be--an advertisement, startling enough, and sometimes maliciously startling, of the artist’s belief that he has the right to be first of all an artist.
THE QUESTIONER. Now we are coming to the point. What _is_ an artist?
THE ARTIST. I told you, a child. And by that, I mean one who _plays_ with his materials--not one who performs a set and perhaps useful task with them. A creator--
THE QUESTIONER. But a creator of what? Not of Beauty, by any chance?
THE QUESTIONER. There we seem to disagree. If those horrid pictures--
THE ARTIST. Suppose _you_ tell me what Beauty is.
THE QUESTIONER. It seems to me quite simple. Beauty is--well--a thing is either beautiful, or it isn’t. And--
THE ARTIST. Just so; the only trouble is that so few of us are able to agree whether it is or isn’t. You yourself have doubtless changed your opinions about what is beautiful many times in the course of your career as an art-lover; and the time may come when you will cherish some horrid nude of Matisse’s as your dearest possession. Let us admit, like the wise old poet, that Beauty is not a thing which can be argued about. It can only be produced.