Harison finally went too far in his shady deals and ruined himself. William Truesdale, one of the small fry who worked for him, owed a debt to a persistent creditor, Joseph Weldon of Boston. Somehow Harison got hold of a dunning letter from Weldon to Truesdale. Just what he had in mind is not clear--a pathetic lament that the historian has to make so often in dealing with what passed for ratiocination in this particular mind--but he caused a warrant to be sworn out against Truesdale in Weldon's name. If you think he simply had his minion arrested without further ado, you do not know Francis Harison. His behavior is described thus by Colden:
Mr Harison met Truesdale at an ale house where, pretending not to like the beer, he invited Truesdale and his company to meet him two hours afterwards at another house. When Truesdale came to the other house he found the Under-Sheriff, who immediately arrested him. Truesdale sends to Mr Harison, as his friend, to help him in his distress. As soon as Mr Harison came, he, in a seeming great surprise, said to Truesdale, "In the name of God, what is this? I hear you are arrested for such a sum"--and blamed him for not informing of it that he might have kept him out of the Sheriff's way.[9]
New York's archvillain must have been very pleased with himself as his victim was carted off to jail. Did he whisper, "Honest Iago!" to himself?
The roguery was there, but as usual there was no intelligence to back it up and make it work. The intriguer had counted on a smooth explanation to fend off the man in whose name he was practicing on Truesdale. Instead, Joseph Weldon felt outraged when he learned what was going on, rushed down from Boston, swore that he never gave anyone any authority to act for him, and added that at the time he did not even know of Harison's existence.
After this scandal there was no place in New York for Francis Harison. Even his protector in the governor's mansion could not save him. A Grand Jury indicted him for using Weldon's name, whereupon he fled from the Colony in May of 1735, made his way to England, and never came back. From then on his story is virtually a blank, the last word on him being that he was down-and-out when he died.